Editorial Policy
Last updated: 2026-10-28
This page lays out how Goodboy Atlas's content is created, reviewed, and revised. The short version: every calculator and article cites real veterinary sources, sponsor money never tilts the math, and we update content when the underlying consensus changes.
Our editorial standard
- Source first. Every calculator formula and every claim of fact is traceable to a published veterinary source (NRC, WSAVA, AAHA, AAFP, peer-reviewed journals, breed associations). Sources are listed at the bottom of each page.
- Honest variance. We show ranges and ±error where they exist, not false-precision single numbers. Pet biology has genuine variation; pretending otherwise is misleading.
- Plain language. If a 12-year-old pet owner can't follow the explanation, the explanation needs fixing — not the reader.
- Vet-deferral by default. Where a decision is medical, we point you to a vet. Calculators are decision-support, not diagnosis.
How we choose sources
Preferred sources, in order:
- Peer-reviewed journal articles (JAVMA, Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery, Journal of Small Animal Practice, British Journal of Nutrition, Veterinary Clinics of North America)
- Veterinary association guidelines (NRC, WSAVA, AAHA, AAFP, AKC)
- Government data (USDA FoodData Central, FDA pet-food regulations)
- Manufacturer disclosures (only for product specs — never for nutritional claims)
We avoid: pet-food brand calculators (conflict of interest), Wikipedia (too unstable for medical content), AI-generated summaries, and uncited blog content — including our own. If we can't find a real source for a claim, we don't make the claim.
Editorial independence from advertising
Goodboy Atlas is intended to be funded by display advertising (Google AdSense); there is no affiliate or sponsored content. There are no affiliate links, product commissions, sponsored placements, or paid content anywhere on this site. We removed the affiliate programme entirely rather than keep a revenue stream that gives us a reason to prefer one product over another. Specifically:
- No commerce, anywhere. No product links earn us money. If a page names a product category, it is because the category is the answer to the question — not because there is a commission attached to it.
- Ad slots are served programmatically by Google. We don't review the individual ads served and we don't endorse them. If you see an ad here that seems misleading, tell us and we'll report it.
- No advertising appears above emergency information, ever. On every toxicity page the poison-hotline numbers and the result come first; any ad unit sits at the very end of the page, after the calculator, the result and the methodology. If your dog has eaten chocolate at 2am, nothing competes for your attention until you have the phone number and the number that matters.
- The most acute emergency pages carry no advertising at all — there are no ad units and no ad script on these pages: cat lily toxicity, cat acetaminophen (Tylenol) toxicity, common toxic foods for dogs, emergency calculators, help, my dog ate…, and their Spanish versions alimentos tóxicos para perros and mi perro comió….
- This is enforced by a build check, not by good intentions. Changes to this policy are logged on the changelog.
- Recommendations in FAQ answers and methodology pages don't promote specific brands beyond what's already a generic example or a citation. If we say "talk to your vet" we mean it — we won't substitute that with a product link.
How we update calculators
Pet nutrition guidelines change rarely (NRC's last major dog/cat update was 2006; AAHA updates roughly every 5–7 years). When the underlying consensus changes, we update the affected calculators within 30 days and the "Updated" date in the page byline changes to match.
Smaller updates — copy clarifications, typo fixes, FAQ additions — are not logged individually. If you spot an error, tell us; we read every email.
Author and reviewer
Carl writes, builds, and maintains Goodboy Atlas. Carl is a long-time pet owner, not a veterinarian. The site does not claim veterinary authority — it provides decision-support tools based on published veterinary research. See about Carl for the bio and qualifications disclosure.
Pages are written by Carl from cited published sources. They are not reviewed by a veterinarian, and no page on this site claims that they are.
Corrections policy
We correct errors openly. Material corrections (math fixes, source replacement, threshold changes) are logged on the public changelog with the date, the affected page and what was changed, and the affected page's byline shows the date of its latest correction. Typo and formatting fixes aren't logged individually.
Out of scope
Goodboy Atlas does not, and will not, cover:
- Veterinary diagnosis — that's a vet's job. We point you to one.
- Individual dosing advice — we do not tell you how much of a medication to give your pet. Toxicity pages summarise published exposure thresholds so you know when to call a vet or poison line; they are not dosing guidance.
- Behavior assessment via questionnaire — too speculative.
- Breed-from-photo identification — requires unreliable ML.
Contact
Editorial questions, source disputes, or correction requests: contact page. Partnership inquiries: /partnership. Both go to a real person.